Research
Post Rebuttal ICML Average Scores? [D]
This Reddit thread on r/MachineLearning is a community discussion where ICML 2025 authors share and compare their post-rebuttal reviewer scores, seeking to gauge where they stand relative to other sub
This Reddit thread on r/MachineLearning is a community discussion where ICML 2025 authors share and compare their post-rebuttal reviewer scores, seeking to gauge where they stand relative to other submissions. The discussion reflects broader community concerns about the ICML review process, including whether rebuttals meaningfully impact scores — a known pain point, as reviewers often acknowledged rebuttals without adjusting scores, leaving authors feeling the rebuttal phase was performative rather than impactful. ICML itself notes that what ultimately matters is the review text rather than the final score, and that area chairs integrate all information into their decisions, meaning average scores should not be taken as a direct indication of the final outcome.
Related
- [[d-dealing-with-an-unprofessional-reviewer-using-fake-referen|[D] Dealing with an unprofessional reviewer using fake references and personal attacks in ICML26]]
- Getting sabotaged by a reviewer at IJCAI [D]
- [[d-how-are-reviewers-able-to-get-away-without-providing-ackno|[D] How are reviewers able to get away without providing acknowledgement in ICML 2026?]]
- ICML 2026 am I cooked? [D]
- Is the ICML 2026 final justification period still open? [R]
Source: r/MachineLearning | 2026-04-11